As the 2024-2025 Vermont high school basketball season progresses, two teams, Middlebury and Rutland, present a contrasting tale of performance, strategies, and prospects. With a snapshot of their records, stats, and head-to-head comparisons, let’s delve into their journey this season.

Team Overview

Middlebury

• Overall Record: 2-5
• Home/Away Split: 1-4 (Home), 1-1 (Away)
• Win Percentage: 28.6%
• Points For (PF): 351
• Points Against (PA): 377

Middlebury has struggled to find consistency this season. Their defense has been a concern, with opponents outscoring them by an average margin. The team averages 50.1 points per game, suggesting room for improvement in both scoring and defensive efficiency.

Rutland

• Overall Record: 6-2
• Home/Away Split: 4-2 (Home), 2-0 (Away)
• Win Percentage: 75%
• Points For (PF): 497
• Points Against (PA): 393

Rutland, on the other hand, has been a powerhouse, boasting a robust offense and a disciplined defense. Their scoring average of 62.1 points per game reflects a well-rounded team capable of controlling games, particularly in the second half, where they often surge ahead.

Performance Breakdown

Scoring Dynamics

Rutland demonstrates balanced scoring across all quarters, with a notable 22-point average in the fourth quarter, highlighting their ability to close games effectively. Middlebury’s scoring pattern is less consistent, often leaving them vulnerable against stronger opponents.

Common Opponents

When comparing performances against shared rivals, Rutland holds an edge. They have a 2-1 record against common opponents, including a dominant 72-33 win over Mount Anthony. Middlebury, conversely, has struggled, going 0-3 in such matchups, with significant losses against Hartford (77-47) and Essex (60-49).

Key Dates and Results

• Middlebury vs. Essex (12/16/24): A 60-49 loss exposed defensive lapses.
• Rutland vs. Essex (12/30/24): A commanding 62-47 win showcased Rutland’s offensive prowess.
• Middlebury vs. Hartford (1/11/25): Another tough loss (77-47) highlighted challenges in competing against top-tier teams.
• Rutland vs. Hartford (1/9/25): While losing 68-61, Rutland’s close margin indicates competitiveness against a strong team.

Season Outlook

Rutland’s strong record and playoff-ready form position them as a leading contender in Vermont’s high school basketball scene. With a flawless league record (2-0) and dominant performances, they are poised for a deep postseason run.

Middlebury, despite a challenging season, has opportunities to recalibrate. Their schedule includes a matchup against Rutland on February 11, 2025—a chance to test themselves against one of the state’s top teams. Improvements in defense and consistent scoring will be pivotal for a stronger finish.

Final Thoughts

The 2024-25 season highlights the contrasting trajectories of Middlebury and Rutland. While Rutland has set the benchmark for success with their balanced gameplay, Middlebury faces a critical period of reflection and growth. As the season progresses, basketball fans across Vermont will watch closely to see how these narratives unfold.