Martinsburg vs. Parkersburg South: A Season Comparison of West Virginia Football Powerhouses

As the high school football season comes to a close, Martinsburg and Parkersburg South have showcased contrasting seasons marked by dominant performances, strategic plays, and individual brilliance. Both teams have made an impact in the 2024-25 season, but their journeys highlight different narratives in West Virginia high school football. Watch Here 

Team Records and Rankings

Martinsburg enters the spotlight as a powerhouse, boasting an impressive 11-0 record and claiming the No. 1 spot in Class 1 rankings. Their dominance is reflected in their perfect 1.000 win percentage both overall and in the region, scoring a staggering 559 points while allowing only 92.

On the other hand, Parkersburg South holds a respectable 6-5 record. Ranked 14th in Class 1 and 8th in the region, they have shown flashes of brilliance but struggled with consistency, as indicated by a win percentage of .545. Their point differential is tighter, with 306 points scored and 317 points allowed, highlighting a more competitive yet challenging season.

Scoring Averages

Martinsburg’s offensive efficiency is evident, averaging 50.8 points per game, with a particularly strong performance in the second quarter, where they score 18.3 points on average. Their ability to set the tone early in games has been crucial to their undefeated season.

In contrast, Parkersburg South averages 27.8 points per game, with their best scoring quarter being the third, averaging 9.2 points. Their lower scoring output suggests a need for more consistency in offensive execution.

Statistical Comparisons

Martinsburg’s balanced attack, with 180 rushing yards per game and 173.5 passing yards, leads to a total of 353.5 yards per game. This versatility makes them a formidable opponent on both the ground and through the air.

Parkersburg South’s numbers, though respectable, fall short of Martinsburg’s dominance, suggesting room for growth in offensive production. Their reliance on key players like Collin Hayes, who averages 161.9 passing yards per game, and Eli Bartley, who contributes 142.1 rushing yards per game, underscores their more individualized approach.

Key Players and Contributions

Martinsburg’s standout performers include:

• Eli Bartley (#11): Leading rusher with 142.1 yards per game and 13.2 points per game.
• Collin Hayes (#9): Dual-threat quarterback, averaging 201.4 total yards per game.
• Cole Middleton (#45): Defensive anchor with 12.3 tackles per game.

Parkersburg South relies heavily on:

• Collin Hayes (#9): Key passer with 161.9 yards per game.
• Logan Middleton (#63): Dominates the line with 16 pancake blocks.

Common Opponents and Playoff Potential

Both teams faced common opponents such as Morgantown, Washington, and Spring Mills, with Martinsburg dominating all matchups, including a decisive 77-7 victory over Parkersburg. Parkersburg South’s 2-2 record against these teams highlights their inconsistency.

Conclusion

Martinsburg’s flawless season underscores their dominance, while Parkersburg South’s resilience highlights their potential. As the season progresses into the playoffs, all eyes will be on Martinsburg to maintain their unbeaten streak, while Parkersburg South will aim to turn their competitive edge into playoff success.